Chaos takes over the Big Ten: UCLA, Indiana and Ohio State all lose in Week 12

play
Michigan stuns No. 4 UCLA 18-16 in 3OT (0:42)

From an entertainment standpoint, the Big Ten delivered an epic Saturday, as No. 4 UCLA, No. 8 Indiana and No. 14 Ohio State were all upset by unranked teams that began the day with losing records in conference play.

But for the conference's playoff purposes, it was a terrible, horrible, no good, very bad Saturday that essentially eliminated Ohio State, put Indiana in a perilous position and risked UCLA's chance of a first-round bye.

It's the Year of Parity across college football, but it's worth considering if this might be the new normal. The conferences are obviously too big. The transfer portal and NIL have become equalizers, and we're left with a bunch of good teams, but no dominant ones. Whether that's good or bad is a matter of preference, but it has created an environment for disingenuous debates about relative strength.

SEC advocates love to talk about depth. Everyone beating up on each other is proof, they reason, that there are no easy weeks in the SEC. It's a logical stance. So logical, in fact, that it can and should apply to the Big Ten and Big 12, too.

Too often, when a middle-of-the-pack SEC team beats a playoff contender, it's viewed as evidence of how good the middle of the SEC is. When the same thing happens elsewhere, somehow those games are twisted to become evidence that the playoff contender was a fraud.

It will be fascinating to see what the committee does with Indiana this week. If any team deserves a little leeway, it probably should be the defending champion -- a program that has won 36 of 40 games under coach Curt Cignetti -- but there seems to be a reluctance to afford the Hoosiers the same latitude that some of the sport's traditional powers enjoy.

For example, Alabama had two losses coming into the week and was ranked No. 3, ahead of six power conference teams (including Notre Dame) with fewer losses despite owning just one win against a team that has a winning record in the SEC (No. 16 Kentucky).

Maybe Alabama really is the third-best team in the country. But maybe it's the ninth or 10th. This isn't to advocate for any team, only to point out that the evidence this late in the year usually is more conclusive. Any intellectually honest analysis of the playoff picture would land in the same place. Instead, we're left with a subjective system that forces stakeholders to lobby publicly to influence the selection process.

"As people assess and look at this football team, it's a different style than maybe I've played historically as a head coach," Tennessee's Josh Heupel said. "And I would think some of the old-time coaches would have a great appreciation that are on that committee -- that style of play, the physicality that we play with. We play field position a little bit more than I have historically and play all three phases of the game together and play it pretty good."

Let's go back to the results and what they likely mean.

Ohio State's 31-28 loss at Nebraska was the latest disappointment in a season that began with national championship aspirations. Receiver Jeremiah Smith turned in another brilliant performance with six catches for 165 yards and a pair of touchdowns. It's hard to argue against the notion that he's the best player in college football, but it's equally difficult envisioning a receiver on a team outside the playoff picture winning the Heisman Trophy.

UCLA's triple-overtime loss to Michigan was disappointing, but not the primary concern after quarterback Ty Dieffenbach was carted off the field in the first overtime because of an injury. The Bruins are already without starter Nico Iamaleava for the season, and the drop-off to third-stringer Madden Iamaleava -- Nico's brother -- from Dieffenbach is significant. UCLA would advance to the Big Ten title game with a win next week against rival USC, but in the event of a loss, all bets are off, with Oregon, Indiana and Iowa still in the mix under different scenarios.

Then, there is Indiana. The Hoosiers twice led in the fourth quarter at Washington before losing 27-24 in overtime, and though a win against Purdue next week would get them to 10-2, it's not a data point that would do anything to enhance their ranking.

The biggest beneficiary of the chaotic day was Oregon, which, just a few weeks ago, was left for dead when it fell to 4-3. Now, the Ducks (8-3) will advance to the Big Ten championship game with a win against Washington next week, where they can secure an automatic playoff berth.

If nothing else, Oregon's rebirth should serve as a reminder of how little separates the teams we've spent the season trying to distinguish from one another.

Jump to:
Miami's regression
Heisman check-in
Down goes Boise State
Closing bell

Miami's regression

The Hurricanes are in a comfortable position to return to the playoff, but that's not all this team is shooting for this season. After losing in the national title game last year, Miami has bigger aspirations. For much of the season, those goals seemed possible, but despite clinching a berth in the ACC title game with a 28-20 win against Virginia Tech, it wasn't a performance that indicated they are peaking at the right time.

play
1:15
Virginia Tech Hokies vs. Miami Hurricanes: Full Highlights

"We coached poorly, we played poorly," coach Mario Cristobal said after the game. "We didn't play to our standard."

He looked justifiably upset.

The good news, though, is that Miami's regression over the past few weeks has coincided with the absence of receiver Malachi Toney, whom Cristobal said Friday was about a week and a half away from returning. They shouldn't need him to beat Boston College next week, but if this team intends to put together another postseason run, Toney's health is paramount. He's one of the best players in college football, and it's hard to understate how much more dangerous the Hurricanes are with him on the field.


Heisman check-in

With Jeremiah Smith's Heisman candidacy in jeopardy as Ohio State fades from relevance, it opens up the likelihood that there will be a more traditional winner: a quarterback from a contending team.

What's interesting about this year's race is that none of the serious candidates likely would have won in any of the previous 20-ish seasons -- maybe longer.

If we're going on stats, the favorite would be Miami's Darian Mensah. He leads the nation in QBR (88.5) and completion percentage (75.4), ranks fourth in passing yards (3,317) and has an incredible touchdown to interception ratio (29 to 4). But there is a strange dynamic with Mensah's candidacy: He's not the best player on Miami's offense. That distinction belongs to Malachi Toney.

How about Georgia's Gunner Stockton? With the Dawgs ranked No. 1, he'll get a lot of votes, but for as efficient as he has been -- 85.0 QBR; 72.4 completion percentage -- his totals are underwhelming. He has yet to throw for at least 300 yards in a game this year, which is a function of Georgia's style, but undoubtedly will hurt his chances.

Utah's Devon Dampier is a fascinating candidate. Dual-threat quarterbacks always fare well in the voting, and he has led the Utes to an 11-0 record. He has continuously delivered in the clutch -- including an 85-yard touchdown pass to help seal the win against TCU on Saturday -- but has also turned the ball over 12 times and doesn't have the same name recognition. By the time voting takes place, he could have around 3,000 yards passing and 800 yards rushing.

CJ Carr checks all the boxes. He ranks No. 6 in QBR, No. 16 in passing yards (2,697) and has thrown 24 touchdowns and just three interceptions. Playing for Notre Dame regularly puts him in the national spotlight, and he outperformed Mensah in a head-to-head game that the Irish won.

The candidate picking up steam late is Wake Forest's Gio Lopez. His numbers are nearly identical to Carr -- in fact, they're marginally better -- and he leads the nation's highest-scoring offense.


Down goes Boise State

The most bizarre coaching sequence of the week goes to Boise State's Spencer Danielson.

Hanging on to a one-point lead after San Diego State failed on a 2-point conversion, the Broncos faced third-and-8 with 1:36 left. SDSU had no timeouts left, so the obvious playcall would have been to run the ball to keep the clock moving and hopefully pick up a first down. Instead, the Broncos threw to the sideline for a gain of 5 yards, but it stopped the clock by going out of bounds. The play was appropriately criticized on the USA Sports broadcast in real time.

From there, the safe call would have been to punt. It would have forced the Aztecs -- again, with no timeouts -- to put together a long drive just to get into field goal territory. Instead, Danielson chose to go for it -- a calculated risk that would either end the game on the spot or give the Aztecs a decent chance to get in field position and win the game. The play never stood a chance. Quarterback Maddux Madsen was sacked, breathing new life into San Diego State, which promptly got the ball into field goal range and won it as time expired.

Danielson led Boise State to the playoff two years ago and had the Broncos on the cusp of a return this year, but this was malpractice. The Broncos will host San Diego State again in two weeks in the Pac-12 title game, but their spot in the playoff is no longer a foregone conclusion.

The most obvious beneficiary is Louisiana Tech. The Bulldogs' only two losses of the season are to LSU and Baylor. So, if they win out, they would be undefeated against the Group of 6 and would have a strong case to displace Boise State in the playoff.

But there are other options.

  • New Mexico. A loss to UNLV last week was a major step back, but if the Lobos win the Mountain West, they'll be in the mix.

  • North Dakota State. The Bison haven't missed a beat in their first year in FBS and control their destiny in the Mountain West.

  • UTSA. A 31-point loss to FAU is a blemish that is tough to ignore, but the Roadrunners have the best record in the American, putting them in the conversation.

  • Liberty. The Flames are 10-1 and are heavy favorites to win Conference USA, but their strength of schedule is limiting.


The closing bell

Buy: Utah

With its 38-17 win against TCU, the Utes should have their playoff spot locked up. Even if they lose to West Virginia next week and then again in the Big 12 title game, they would be sitting at 11-2, and that should be enough.

Sell: SEC vs. FCS games

Anyone who defends SEC teams playing FCS opponents, let alone this deep in the season, needs to check their bias. It's ridiculous and indefensible.

Hold: BYU

A triple-OT win against Kansas isn't the way to prove you are worthy of the playoff, but winning is winning. Look for all of the SEC apologists to cry for BYU to be penalized, but so long as BYU wins next week against Cincinnati, it should safely be in the playoff field.

play
1:07
BYU escapes with a triple-overtime win at Kansas

Buy: Stanford

The Cardinal are bowl-eligible. At the start of the season, the prospect of that happening seemed grim at best. So, credit to Tavita Pritchard for coming in and reshaping what might be possible in Year 1. The last time Stanford won more than four games was 2018.

Sell: Cal

On the other side of the Bay, expectations were sky-high with the arrival of Tosh Lupoi. Instead, the Golden Bears turned in one of their most disappointing seasons in modern history, raising questions about whether Lupoi might not make it past Year 1.

Buy: North Dakota State

The Bison didn't play to their standard in a win against Northern Illinois, but in their first year in FBS, they are a victory from playing for the Mountain West title. It feels like only a matter of time before the longtime FCS power qualifies for the CFP.

Buy: Liberty

After cracking the AP poll at No. 22, Liberty won its 10th straight game to improve to 10-1 -- a drastic improvement from last season, when the Flames went just 4-8.

Sell: Kentucky

When Kentucky started the season 7-1, it looked like one of the best stories of the season. Now, three straight losses later, the Wildcats are just another team in the crowd.

Buy: Making up

With Georgia Tech trailing Wake Forest by 28 points in the fourth quarter, a young couple's argument became fodder for the ESPN broadcast, which happened to have Jesse Palmer, the host of ABC's "The Bachelor" and "The Bachelorette," as the game analyst. Naturally, this moment went viral, with social media left to fill in the blanks.

We have to assume the couple's phones lit up with messages about their newfound fame before their happy ending.

Sell: UMass

Say it ain't so. The Minutemen's march to a bowl game felt inevitable after a 4-0 start. But after a 34-33 loss to lowly Akron on Wednesday, they need a win at Bowling Green next week to reach six wins.

Buy: Celebratory in-game beer

Holy Cross linebacker Adam Due's game-sealing interception against Fordham was just a precursor to the iconic moment that followed: a healthy pull from a fan's beer behind the sideline. Legend.